Solvency in doubt? Importance of directors documenting their decisions

In the complex world of business, directors of UK companies face numerous challenges, especially when navigating the murky waters of potential insolvency. 

One critical aspect often overlooked is the importance of meticulously documenting decisions made during such times. This practice not only safeguards the directors but also ensures compliance with legal obligations.

Understanding Wrongful Trading and Fiduciary Duties

Section 214 of the Insolvency Act 1986 addresses the concept of wrongful trading. 

This occurs when directors continue to trade despite knowing, or having reasonable grounds to believe, that there is no reasonable prospect of avoiding insolvent liquidation. 

If found guilty of wrongful trading, directors can be held personally liable for the company's debts. 

Therefore, it is imperative for directors to be acutely aware of their fiduciary duties under the Companies Act, which include acting in the best interests of the company and its creditors. With added emphasis on the interest of creditors at times of uncertainty.

The Cash Flow and Balance Sheet Tests for Insolvency

Directors must be vigilant in monitoring the company's financial health. 

Two key tests are used to determine insolvency: the cash flow test and the balance sheet test. 

The cash flow test assesses whether the company can pay its debts as they fall due, while the balance sheet test evaluates whether the company's liabilities exceed its assets. 

Regularly applying these tests can help directors identify early signs of financial distress and take appropriate action.

The Role of Documentation

Documenting decisions is not just a bureaucratic exercise; it is a vital tool for directors to demonstrate that they have acted responsibly and in good faith. 

Detailed records of board meetings, financial assessments, and the rationale behind key decisions can provide a robust defence against allegations of wrongful trading. These records should include:

1. Regular Meetings: Directors should hold frequent meetings to discuss the company's financial status and the reasons for continuing to trade. These meetings should be minuted, capturing the discussions and decisions made.
2. Professional Advice: Seeking advice from financial advisors, accountants, or insolvency practitioners is crucial. Documenting the advice received and the actions taken based on that advice can further strengthen the directors' position.
3. Financial Assessments: Regularly updating and documenting financial assessments, including cash flow forecasts and balance sheet evaluations, is essential. This demonstrates that the directors are actively monitoring the company's financial health.

Potential Consequences for Failing to Document Decisions

Failing to properly document decisions can have severe consequences for directors. Without adequate records, directors may struggle to prove that they acted in the best interests of the company and its creditors. This lack of documentation can lead to:

1. Personal Liability: Directors may be held personally liable for the company's debts if they cannot demonstrate that they took reasonable steps to avoid wrongful trading.
2. Disqualification: Directors found guilty of wrongful trading or failing to fulfill their fiduciary duties may face disqualification from holding directorships in the future.
3. Reputational Damage: Legal actions and financial penalties can tarnish a director's reputation, making it difficult to secure future roles in other companies.
4. Legal Penalties: In addition to personal liability, directors may face legal penalties, including fines and other sanctions, for failing to comply with their legal obligations.

Seeking Professional Advice

In times of financial uncertainty, obtaining advice from an insolvency practitioner can be invaluable. These professionals can provide an objective assessment of the company's situation and recommend the best course of action. 

Documenting this advice and the subsequent decisions made can help directors show that they have taken all reasonable steps to mitigate potential risks.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the importance of documenting decisions when trading whilst potentially insolvent cannot be overstated. 

Directors must be proactive in monitoring the company's financial health, seeking professional advice, and maintaining detailed records of their decisions. 

By doing so, they not only fulfil their legal obligations but also protect themselves from personal liability and ensure the long-term viability of the business.

Get in touch with us

Our Business Restructuring Team offers expert, practical advice on restructuring or recovery to strengthen and protect your business.